Skip to content

Digital marketing

Nine Digital Marketing Agency Claims to Check Before You Sign

Most agencies marketing their services online promise growth. Some of those promises are fair; others are impossible or quietly misleading. These nine digital marketing agency claims are worth testing before you sign anything.

5 min read
Digital marketing agency claims to check by LogDart: checklist, magnifying glass and shield with a tick

In short

  • Nobody can guarantee rankings or a fixed number of leads.
  • Ask for evidence you can check: real work, real reviews and reports with real numbers.
  • Make sure your accounts and website stay in your name, whatever the agency promises.
Contents

Agencies marketing their services online all promise growth, and many deliver it. But some digital marketing agency claims sound better than they are. Here are nine common claims, what they really mean and how to test them before you commit.

1. "We guarantee first-page rankings"

Nobody controls Google's results, so nobody can guarantee a position. Agencies that make this promise either target phrases nobody searches for or use shortcuts that risk penalties. Ask which exact searches they mean and how many people make them each month.

2. "You will get leads from day one"

Paid ads can bring enquiries quickly, but the first weeks are spent learning which searches and messages convert. SEO takes longer. Ask what results are realistic in the first month and the first quarter, and what happens if they are not met.

3. "We will get you thousands of followers"

Followers are easy to buy and almost worthless if they are not real buyers. Ask how followers will turn into enquiries, and avoid any agency that buys followers, likes or reviews.

4. "Our package includes 30 posts a month"

A number of posts tells you about activity, not results. Ask what each post is meant to achieve and how the agency will measure whether social media is bringing enquiries.

5. "We are a Google Partner"

Partner badges show that an agency meets certain requirements for managing Google Ads. They are useful, but they do not prove the agency suits your business. Ask to see work for clients like you.

6. "We handle everything, you don't need to do anything"

Every good agency needs your input: knowledge of your customers, quick approvals and honest feedback on lead quality. An agency that needs nothing from you is probably guessing.

7. "Our reporting dashboard shows everything"

Dashboards can hide as much as they show. Ask for a sample monthly report and check whether it shows spend, enquiries, cost per lead and what will change next, in plain language.

8. "We set everything up for you"

Setting up is good; owning is not. Make sure your ad accounts, Analytics, Google Business Profile, domain and website are in your name, with the agency given access.

9. "We work with hundreds of happy clients"

Big numbers are easy to claim. Ask for two or three case studies you can check and reviews from real people at real businesses. Be wary of testimonials with no name, photo or company.

How to test any claim

A simple rule works for every promise: ask for evidence you can check yourself. Real work you can look at, real people you can speak to and reports with real numbers. An agency that is proud of its results will be happy to show them.

It also helps to compare two or three proposals side by side. When one agency promises far more than the others for the same budget, ask what it is doing differently. Usually the answer is a smaller target, a riskier method or a definition of a lead that counts things you would not.

For a full list of questions to ask before signing, read our guide on how to choose a digital marketing agency.

How we handle this for clients

We do not promise rankings, follower counts or a fixed number of leads. What we promise is a written plan, tracking set up before money is spent, the same people from the first call to the monthly review and a report that shows what came back for what was spent.

If something is not working, we say so in the report and explain what we will change. Your accounts and website stay in your name throughout.

Questions about agency promises

Can any agency guarantee a first-page ranking on Google?

No. Google decides its own rankings and changes them often. An agency can improve your chances with good technical work, content and links, but a guarantee usually means the target search is too small to matter or the methods are risky.

Is it a bad sign if an agency offers a fixed number of posts?

Not by itself, but it is a measure of activity rather than results. Ask what the posts are meant to achieve and how the agency will show whether social media is bringing enquiries or sales.

What does a Google Partner badge mean?

It means the agency meets Google's requirements for managing Google Ads accounts, including spend and performance thresholds. It is a useful sign, but it does not prove the agency understands your industry or will get results for you.

How can I check an agency's case studies?

Look for named clients, links to the live website or campaign and specific details about what changed. Where possible, contact the client or check their reviews. Case studies with no names or details are hard to trust.

What should I do if an agency refuses to give me account access?

Treat it as a serious warning. Your ad accounts, analytics, domain and website should belong to you. If an agency insists on keeping them in its own name, look elsewhere or make ownership a condition in the contract.

Keep reading